BBC Rugby Union: Concerns Raised Over World Rugby’s Scrum Law Change
Former Test referee Nigel Owens has expressed his worries about World Rugby’s decision to amend the scrum law, set to take effect from July 1. Under the new rule, teams will no longer be allowed to call a scrum when a free-kick has been awarded, sparking concerns that it could diminish the significance of this crucial set-piece.
Owens, a highly respected former match official, believes that this change is more likely to create further problems than solve the existing ones. He argues that the scrum is an integral part of the game, providing an opportunity for front-row players to utilize their strength and physicality to benefit their teams. Owens fears that the new law could lead to more gamesmanship from sides with weaker scrums, undermining the original intent.
“We simply have to ensure that the scrum remains an integral part of the game. If it’s not, then we are going to lose these players – and damage the game itself,” Owens wrote in his WalesOnline column.
World Rugby’s rationale for the change is that reducing the number of scrums will open up attacking opportunities. However, Owens strongly disagrees, suggesting that the space created by the scrum setup is crucial for teams to launch effective attacks. He believes that the new law could lead to more kicking and continuous pick-and-go play, potentially reducing the excitement and spectacle of the game.
“Imagine Wales were playing England in Cardiff and the Welsh scrum shoved the English pack back a couple of metres for a try. The roof would be blown off the stadium and that’s how it should be,” Owens added.
The former referee emphasizes that rugby has always been a sport that celebrates diversity, with a place for players of all shapes and sizes. He fears that the scrum law change could disproportionately impact the front-row players, who are the “bread and butter” of the game.
Owens ultimately believes that this decision by World Rugby is more likely to increase negativity and reward poor scrummaging, potentially leading to the gradual disappearance of the scrum altogether. He argues that the governing body should reconsider this move and ensure that the scrum remains an integral and exciting part of the game for rugby enthusiasts.
🔗 Source
